All the latest gaming news, game reviews and trailers. Wynter is my writing heroine/idol. I will try not say which one is “better”, but point out the key differences and leave the decision up to you. On March 31, 2016, FUNimation Entertainment's license to the series expired. Your best, or even the best that could possibly be done in a given situation, isn’t going to be good enough every time. I haven’t watched Brotherhood yet, but from what I can tell, I feel like it will be better than the original due to it having the same source material from the beginning rather than changing the storyline halfway. fma doesn't have anything to do with the first fma series or the movie. They were always busy doing their own thing, and while fans knew it was there, it never really came to light. Honestly, this series are terrible. Get your own blog or write your own damn article. Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood (FMAB) FMAB se trouve être la deuxième adaptation du même Full Metal Alchemist. They’re great! The success of the original and the manga meant that the makers of brotherhood had a far easier time geting far more money for production than FMA 03, and it showed. RELATED: Fullmetal Alchemist: 10 Cool Facts You Didn't Know About Lust. Things die and the world keeps moving on, even without him. The plotlines relatively hold the same essence, both feature Ed and Al trying to find the Philosopher's Stone to get their bodies back. But that’s why it make the two brothers so stood out, because the two were alone (and dependent on each other) in their struggle against everything else. Also, I think it depends how you are defining animation – it sounds like you are referring to the entire show in general? Feminity, gender roles, and girl power in magical girl anime, Existentialism in Shounen Anime and Manga. I honestly don’t like brotherhood. Brotherhood was definitely an improvement all across the board. It does go in a very different direction and is unrecognizable after the first 8 or so episodes. Really nicely explained. Dropped FMA 2003 due to the lack of everything: terrible character development, terrible story pacing, literally nothing happens until they kill a certain character. Cette série animée a été convertie en 64 épisodes et diffusée à la télévision en 2009 et 2010. But I will give it a go now! Needless to say, I find Brotherhood’s final episode completely satisfying. They are memorable and lovable – this is mostly the reason you can follow the show for so long, you learn to care about all the characters. Brotherhood is a direct adaption of the manga, and thus triggers the halo effect. Brotherhood indeed is a near exact match on the manga in animated form. I watched the 2003 version first on TV years ago and then watched Brotherhood more recently. Many of the Homunculi and their stories are vastly different between the two shows, sometimes even having different characters completely. Thank you for this! okay i know i’m a little late i watched fma a couple months ago and and i watched the 2003 one first and I LOVE IT i didnt really like brotherhood. Is it really that good? Which one is better? Prove you are human, type cats in singular form below: The Artifice is a long-form writing platform that covers a wide spectrum of art forms. You can’t save everyone. Pride was made by the Father as the first Homunculus. When the first Fullmetal Alchemist series aired in October 2003, five volumes of the manga had been released, with the sixth arriving later that month. I found that the 2003 version did a better job at the first 15 episodes than Brotherhood did, I think 2003 also did the Tucker Arc better emotionally. Ed, the soldier/dog of the military, kills. And will i understand brotherhood if i didn't watch the original full metal alchemist? Which version should I watch?” This is what I hope to decipher for you. My own personal gripe with Brotherhood is the Nina arc didn’t make me cry, but perhaps its because I had already seen the original! It did the polar opposite. The Way Back (帰路) Equivalent Exchange (等価交換) Melissa (TV size ver.) This results in two sets of complex characters, the homunculi, and the ones that made them. But if your gonna start a series watch the 2003 one. And i agreed with your point of view on it. Or skip those episodes too. While Catherine Elle Armstrong makes appearances in both series, she is the only sister the Major has in Fullmetal Alchemist (2003). This is why I preferred Brotherhood which I finished last year. The story just tied together better in my opinion in FMA: B, but FMA had some good ideas, they just didn’t tie together well to me. FMAB aired on our local stations first. Good review. PS. Stupid sanafabitchis more fitting. I think FMAB is better just cause it how Arakawa visualized the story. Even 6 years later, anime can sometimes have hideous visuals. Backgrounds were nicely drawn, and action scenes were smooth. To be honest… I can respect Brotherhood for the simple fact that it gave a complete story. The main difference, FMA Brotherhoods stuck in its shounen genre, where things are black and white. Continue browsing in r/FullmetalAlchemist. Read the manga xD Buy the manga box set, it’s awesome. Puis, la série a été diffusée du 26 septembre 2010 à fin décembre 2010 sur MCM dans l'émission Ultra Manga présentée par Noémie Alazard5. But when it can!e time to go back around and see then consequences of your actions, to see how the world REALLY responded to our heroes efforts, and what effect that would have on them… The manga never tried. Square Enix announces a collaboration event between Fullmetal Alchemist and Final Fantasy Brave Exvius that will … In the original series, Homunculi were actually made by people who tried to bring someone back from the dead. I started writing about anime when I was 15 and it looked far worse than this. Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood is an alternate retelling of Hiromu Arakawa's Fullmetal Alchemist manga that is closer to the source material than the previous 2003 adaptation, this time covering the entire story. fma brotherhood follows the manga, which the first one does not. How can one easily accept a long gone father where you missed his love from the childhood, the misery of losing mom, and the suffering of the journey to pay off the karma? It varied a lot – from mediocre to excellent. He wanted to stop greed, he had the means to stop him… Maybe up to that moment he thought he could pull it off without killing greed, perhaps he thought that faced with the possibility of death greed would become reasonable… Ed learned the hard lesson that day as well. The lovers of anime and manga know the abbreviations FMA and FMAB very well but for those who are not aware; these are anime series of the same story Full Metal Alchemist. And yes, i see this is an old post. Akira: An Analysis of the A-Bomb and Japanese Animation, Daria and the Clichéd Representation of Teenagers, The Good Fight: The Real, The Plausible, and Donald Trump’s Legacy, Cells at Work! This article AND thread are amazing. I think it was 2012 or so. RELATED: Full Metal Alchemist: The 10 Biggest Changes The First Anime Made To The Story. This clearly showed as well…. One of the biggest differences between Fullmetal Alchemist and Brotherhood lies in its villains. Regarding the brothers in both series all went through pain, loss of blood and sweat, but the lost in FMA appeared to be greater. Just why? I also enjoy both. Some new faces make the scene – which is a nice extra. Thank u very much . Its downfall would have to be the number of stills. At the end of the series, just before the movie, there was a bit of a back and forth between Ed and Al's body. Fullmetal Alchemist is an iconic anime that has been recommended countless times over the past decade. That means that Bones, the animation studio behind Fullmetal Alchemist, had only a fragment of the ultimately 27-v… Afterall human still looking for an answer of how the world is created, so I don’t mind if the plot wasn’t well explained in FMA. Holy shit… “For its time, the 2003 version…” … so much ignorance in that sentence. Saw Brotherhood on Netflix and started thinking about FMA all over again, and lookie what I stumbled onto. Brotherhood/Manga ed: naive child who believed he could get everything he wanted if he tried really hard and nothing bad would ever happen to good people, nobody needs to die, I’ll protect them all! The two share the body, Ling allowing Greed to take over when they're in a fight or he needs to say something. Youve had this much time to change/edit/rehash it. Yes, I remember Brotherhood making more sense, but it just didn’t have the power the original did. Brotherhood is longer than the original – 64 episodes long, but was more reliable to the manga (2001-10). Watch FMA up until Lab 5 and then give yourself a break….then go to Brotherhood and watch the 12 summarized episodes of the 25 you just watched. Two reasons why I want to watch the original fma is because my brothers who are way older than me watched it along with other great animes that aired in the philippines in early and late 2000s and wanted to know what it felt like watching the shows they used to love. The entire cast shares a happily ever after. I agree with Kai though, Ling Yao is epic!! . Now Brotherhood is an entirely different matter. Although using this technology was faster and far cheaper than FMA03’s hand painting, it did not always look better, particularly in some of that background and environment art during certain lighting conditions…. I agree with you totally. In both series, Ed was always very self-conscious about his height. When Brotherhood was announced I was ecstatic but wasn't able to catch any late-night viewings for reasons, so I had to binge-watch it via the magic of bittorrent. Even though Mustang wins (kinda) at the end of the original, I think you get way more of him in Brotherhood which is a plus cause he’s dumb lit (get it???). Just as I wouldn’t expect an anime has a perfect action packed, developed characters, soundtrack, and story every time, makes it less expectable. By the end of the series, Lust acts as one of the good guys even with all the bad that she has done. And make the existence of homonculus more reaaonable. However, the backstory of each Homunculus and their true nature are completely altered. I had to admit, when I watched Brotherhood at that time, (think it was around 2009), I had completely forgot most of the older FMA series, but from what I can remember, as compared to when I was watching Brotherhood, I still like the latter more, especially characters-wise, Brotherood has quite a better character cast overall, new characters like Ling Yao kicks ass , gonna have to agree here, anyways it was a good article overall. I love the music and the deep story of both. Media creation technology was movingbat warp speeds in the early 2000’s, a year was an eternity, but 6…. The 2003 anime was made while the manga was serializing and since it caught up with the manga release schedule, it diverged paths and has a completely different story. And am I the only one missing the truly silly moments of the 03 series, because they kind of softened the blow of tragic events later on? That opening is way too nostalgic. So I went back to the 03 to see if I was just crazy, and the way 03 sets up the story and the characters is…strikingly superior. Some people can’t be reasoned with, and if they aren’t stopped, others will die. I actually like Brotherhood much more. '03 has the more emotionally satisfying beginning. The core difference between the two anime is how liberally they adapt the manga. I agree with gpdc (above comments), I’m watch Brotherhood first than the 2003. For that reason I believe it should be seen first. You remember all their names, and that is a great achievement. The story just made much more sense & the elements tied together much better in FMA:B than in FMA. By Joseph Clark Dec 25, 2020 … Juliana Failde is a writer for CBR, Screen Rant, and the Sartorial Geek. This is why I prefer FMA 2003… it even gave chilling moments. I enjoyed it immensely from start to finish. I feel justified in my opinion haha. It seems the general consensus is the Brotherhood ending is superior to that of the original though. Perhaps it was because I didn’t see it aired on TV that I didn’t feel the same cliffhanger experience – to me, while there is still a story, and it is entertaining, it didn’t grip me as much. I also like darker anime & the 2003 version definitely gave me a more adult anime feel verses Brotherhood, which was vibrant in color but just as well a little safer for ages. How Fullmetal Alchemist and Brotherhood Are Different. I actually saw Brotherhood first and I agree that it is the better one. There were a lot of differences between the shows by the end, mostly the homunculi. Nicely explained. 1 decade ago. I really liked what I saw but came to find out later just how much it had diverged from the original work. There is no reason to rage that hard at someone. Oh wow. It will absorb Xehanort and become Kairi's grandma, the final villain!!! Some characters in the anime aren’t in the manga or are different versions between the anime and manga. On the other hand, the little bitter end without those cheesy love relationship of Ed and Winry was actually made pretty to the story, so to the pure brotherhood. Female University student. I watched FMA 2003 first and I liked the story, but it got me real confused after the introduction of Research Lab 5. Years ago I watched a handful of episodes of the original series as they aired on tv and found it interesting but a bit cartoonish and overly dramatic. Let’s just be glad BONES only improves on its trade, and Brotherhood was the 2003 version with a visual make over. Excellent article, you have comments for years! Then there are things like mustang being the one who killed Winrey’s parents because he was practically broken from learning how to survive the horrors of war. (Cliff hanger til the end). Izumi's child and Ed's mother both stayed dead after their attempted resurrections failed. i still quite confuse in the stories timeline and plot. Something brotherhood skipped over. Good and evil. The two have a strange yet special bond that actually makes Greed one of the good guys as he ends up helping the Elric brothers throughout the second half of the show. Whitney. It also fills in some gaps that are glossed over in Brotherhood. Lastly, gotta shout out my boy Maes Hughes. Known as the Ice Queen, Olivier Mira Armstrong's official title is Major General and is the heir to the Armstrong family. She gains morality and has a hard time choosing between good and evil once she meets her past life's lover. I don’t think I have ever been so disappointed in reading a manga after an anime more than I was with FMA. Pride was made by the Father as the first Homunculus. I will try not say which one is “better”, but point out the key differences and leave the decision up to you.First thing is first: this is a great show for anime newbie… Al finally gets placed in his own body again but is 10 years old and has no memories of their journey. Xehanort's guardian is the will of Kairi's grandma. FMA03 Tortured artificial sentient existence the result of an alchemist that has the immediate knowledge to do something, usually acquired at the behest of burning driving motivation (such as the death of a loved one), but not the knowledge or experience to know what it really means to do such a thing. He did some bad that opposed the brothers, but fans got to see that he was just troubled all along. RELATED: Fullmetal Alchemist: 5 Ways It's Different From The Manga (& 5 Ways It's The Same). Did you make an account just to insult her? The best animation is found during the 80s-90s period, FMA being a rare and pleasant surprise. Ed was also more whiney in FMA & in FMA B you got to see him be a bit tougher or grow into being tougher & stronger even though he still had his moments. 2: False Light, Truth's Shadow (偽りの光 真実の影, Itsuwari no Hikari, Shinjitsu no Kage) and Fullmetal Alchemist Vol. The subject matter is incredibly interesting and this universe has been extremely well thought out – almost to Harry Potter standards. So anyway, I googled a comparison to see what other people thought, to see if it was worth delving into Brotherhood, just to revisit the characters with that fresher animation look, and your review pinpointed everything I was feeling just in the span of those three episodes. La série est disponible sur Netflix depuis le 1 avril 2017. I was also able to follow the story of Brotherhood more easily than FMA 2003. Especially the end. Brother hood was great but FMA original is just too classic to me. There are some things I like better in the 2003 version. Both are good, it’s just a matter of preferences. I’ve liked all versions/seasons of this show. Sure, it follows the manga but most anime stray from manga in some form or another. The problem with 2003 is that it spins off from the source but otherwise it’s a very good implementation, I did not mind the twist and the different story back then and I don’t now – It’s very good for it’s time. While the original had its flaws, it didn’t warrant a remake. Thanks again for the article, all the way in 2018. Fullmetal Alchemist is an anime about two brothers, Edward and Alphonse Elric, who are out to find the Philosopher's Stone to restore Al's body and Ed's arm and leg, which they lost in an attempt to bring back their mother. In 2003, there is Cornello who can alchemy weapon, and i think it was no logic (in equivalent exchange, even after that we know he can do that because of Philosopher Stone). I still watched it through the last episode but my enthusiasm for it dropped considerably. Did you know this trick? Aww X-x thanks – I didn’t think I was that good at writing! I enjoying logic in Brotherhood than 2003 series in many aspect. And in the red corner, a whopping 64 episodes is the newer, shinier anime adventures of the Elric brothers, Full Metal Alchemist: Brotherhood! I am not much of an anime fan, but as a current pharmacy student, I’ve always had an interest in alchemy. Some spoilers ahead, just wanted to shout out my opinion and read some others. I’m about to dive into FMA:B right now. In the 2003 series, she was used a lot more and even became relevant to the final arc of the series. Thank you, Donna! Brotherhood Ed is a child in comparison even at the end of the series. Like Greed, Lust's story between the two series is vastly different, but unlike Greed, she strives more in the 2003 series rather than in Brotherhood. Evil beings split off from an evil artificial dust ball, with a groovy grin. Maybe it’s because I watched 2003 first and then brotherhood but I feel like it lacks the depth that 2003 had. While the 2003’s soundtrack was good, I found myself liking the overall sound of the BGM here a lot more than the original, despite Bratja of course! Many of the scenes in Brotherhood are near identical to some of the manga panels as well. I thought it an was an informative article. The vast majority of VA from the original FMA 03 dub came back to reprise their roles, this means that from the very first recording session, these actors were already familiar and comfortable with their roles, foregoing that awkward phase pretty much ALL shows go through where the actors learn to settle in to the characters. Want to write about Anime or other art forms? No lessons learned, bad guys gone and now everyone has a happy ending. Fullmetal Alchemist is a shounen manga written by Hiromu Arakawa, with two anime adaptations, both made by Studio Bones. As an avid anime fan I tend to fully avoid duplicate productions as a fundimental rule . Im a huge fan of anime sticking to original adaptations, more so after Tokyo Ghoul RE. 10 Times Boruto Was Actually Better Than Naruto: Shippuden, 10 Major Ways Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood Differs From The Original Anime, differences that totally change the structure, Fullmetal Alchemist: 5 Ways It's Different From The Manga (& 5 Ways It's The Same), Fullmetal Alchemist: 10 Cool Facts You Didn't Know About Lust, Full Metal Alchemist: The 10 Biggest Changes The First Anime Made To The Story, 15 Anime To Watch If You Like Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood, Naruto: 10 Memes That Totally Speak To Our Souls, Attack On Titan: 5 Characters Who Should Be Dead (& 5 Who Shouldn't Be), Naruto: 10 Characters Who Should Invest In Taijutsu, My Hero Academia: 5 Best Offensive Quirks (& 5 Best Support Quirks), Bleach: 10 Things You Didn't Know About Ichigo Kurosaki, Fairy Tail: 10 Anime Characters Who Are Just Like Erza Scarlet, Savage #1 Gives Valiant's Ultimate Survivalist a Punk Rock Relaunch, Space Bastards #1 Is an Action-Packed, Sci-Fi Adventure, King in Black: Thunderbolts #1 Introduces a New Marvel Dirty Dozen, Future State: Teen Titans #1 Weaves a Tragedy for DC's Young Heroes, Review: Haha #1 Offers a Dark Set of Tales Starring Clowns, Future State: Justice League #1 Is an Exciting, Bold Shift, Naruto: 10 Plot Points That Were Abandoned Before The Ending, Naruto: 15 Couples That Would Have Made A Lot Of Sense (But Never Got Together), 10 Anime To Watch If You Liked Cells At Work, Naruto: 10 Characters Who Deserved To Pass The Chunin Exams (& Why), Naruto: Every Great Ninja War In The Story, Explained, Naruto: 10 Strongest Shinobi Who Fought In The Second Great Ninja War, Boruto: 10 Things That Annoyed Even Dedicated Fans, JoJo's Bizarre Adventure: 5 Anime Characters Okuyasu Can Defeat (& 5 He Can't), Hunter X Hunter: 10 Ways Killua Has Grown Stronger Since He Was Introduced, Blue Exorcist: Rin's 10 Strongest Abilities, Ranked. It was released when the manga was finishing – so in a way ‘Brotherhood’ could be seen as the ‘true’ Fullmetal Alchemist story. First thing is first: this is a great show for anime newbies. By the end of the series, Ed is almost an entire head taller than her. Turned out for the best. Every character story is a tragic in itself, where both alchemy and ultimately the seven sins were just the corruption of all good. Lv 4. Plus, you can’t make such sweeping generalizations like this. However, in the original series, the couple didn't really get too much screentime. Since it got original content that early, and the tone is already different from the beginning. Brotherhood is quite disorientating in terms of the characters, because a lot of them (especially the bad guys) have different roles – however, once you get used to the ‘changes’ they are still just as likable as ever. The author of this review talks as if animation has gotten better with time, which only shows his ignorance in the matter. Brotherhood Traditional alchemy also talks about equipment exchange, but comes from the earth power. Truly, imho, you will not regret watching FMA. 2003 also have much superior soundtrack. She is part of one of the first major arcs in both series but, as far as Brotherhood is concerned, that's pretty much it. Which version should I watch?” This is what I hope to decipher for you. I am cringing so hard at this post. She is the oldest out of the three siblings and can definitely take her brother in a fight. The argument begins at, which is the better story, the one laid out in the manga, or the one FMA 03 came up with. I also feel the episodes that cross over before the story lines deviate are very rushed in Brotherhood. By the time it ended in October 2004, a year later exactly, eight volumes had been published. I think Brotherhood is better although it seems to show a little bit more about Mustang and the politics of Central a lot more than in FMA, but FMA is a little better than Brotherhood in length wise with explaining the story. However, for me I felt Brotherhood was more rushed and about the world where the original I felt was about the true love the brothers had for one another. But in brotherhood, they skip it to make it more logic, they make the first epispde with ice alchemy and other basic alchemy. I’m a huge fan of FMA and my wife and I are just now watching FMA:B. I’m not a big anime fan but love these. Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood is NOT a sequel, it is an anime adaptation of the manga. And if i didnt, i would have wrote my own opinions and why i felt that way. However being taught a lesson, even out in the field, and experiencing the brutal reality first hand, are two very, very different things, which this Ed found out first hand, he carried that weight. There is a lot of ‘talking heads’, with little happening in terms of body language or in the background. Craig Elvy Jun 9, 2020. However, in Brotherhood, as Ed's character matured and developed, he began to grow taller. Original Poster 1 point ... (usually idrc but FMA brotherhood hit different) View Entire Discussion (21 Comments) More posts from the FullmetalAlchemist community. Screenfice covers the latest Film & TV news. Both versions of the story feature the Homunculi as recurring enemies for the Elric brothers, and since these characters appear early, their basic function and overarching seven deadly sins theme remain consistent. Fullmetal Alchemist & Final Fantasy Are Teaming Up. Brotherhood, being made so many years later, and with the benefit of the manga and the FMA 03 being so successful has certain advantages the original just didn’t have. Brotherhood only has a few episodes wortb noting. At the end of the series, the two share a deep hug that may imply their emotions for one another but nothing is ever really said about the matter as Ed goes his own way. A far greater consequence than what he had to deal with in brotherhood. In both series, he is one of the first main antagonists and is incredibly strong, testing Ed and Al more than almost anyone else.