I tried to do a side by side comparison on both and since I heard that the picnic would finish sooner, I put the probe in it and monitored from there. It is worked harder on the animal, so it can be tougher. and the butt is $3.19/lb. The shoulder (also sometimes called the picnic shoulder) can be found right below the butt and sits at the top part of the pig leg. Understanding the subtleties of these cuts can assist you with bettering pick which to purchase, and how to cook them both. Thread starter KenB; Start date Dec 10, 2014; K. KenB TVWBB Fan. From purchasing a pork shoulder to the prep and cooking that occurs before it hits your table, this is what you have to know to ace this piece of meat. Utilized for some, things, including Porchetta di Testa, or a salami produced using both the meat and skin of a pig head. The shoulder area of a pig has a lot of flavorful aroma and fat since it is an area that witnesses a lot of activity when the pig is alive. Without proper cooking, it very well may be extreme. This muscle isn’t utilized as much by the pig as the outing shoulder. I've cooked both Boston butt and picnic ham for barbecue, and picnic definitely takes more time. All that work of walking around gives the shoulder a ton of flavor it likewise provides that cut with which is a ton of surface. To find out more, visit our cookies policy and our privacy policy. “Or then again you can envelop them by tin foil, toss them in a 300-degree stove for 1.5 to 2 hours,” says Mylan. Indeed, you got that right: the butt doesn’t originate from anyplace close to the back of the creature. The lower part of the shoulder becomes a picnic roast, a narrower cut like the shank end of a ham. Also, it’s imperative to take note of that the cuts accessible at the essential food item will change contingent upon topography – butchers from Argentina will sell marginally unexpected slices in comparison to, state, butchers from Italy. I have done one picnic shoulder and I will try to always get the Boston/Shoulder Butt from now on. All rights reserved. In this guide, we’re going to ensure you know all the significant insights concerning this frugal cut of meat. But cook it low and slow, and it just melts away, basting the meat with all sorts of savory juices. The midsection is super – you can do a wide range of stuff with a belly.”, Save ribs fall off of the abdomen. To season this whole pork shoulder, use a simple salt and pepper mix. It has less marbling and less fat. There are a few occurrences where we choose this cut over Boston butt. Both cuts actually come from the pig's shoulder. Try not to stress over destroying pork shoulder. Also, why is the shoulder of the hog sometimes called "Picnic Ham"? Normally a Boston butt will be rectangular in shape. Side note: Why is this cut some of the time called “pork butt” when it doesn’t originating from the real backside? The pork butt comprises parts of the neck, shoulder bone, and upper arm of the pig. The genuine back of the pig is known as the ham. Or bracket it up and cook it before cutting the meat into distinctive emblems. As for bone or no bone; it depends on flavor to me. Boston butt comes from high on the hog, above the shoulder blade, and has lots of juicy, marbled fat. “At the point when you see rivalry grill,” proficient butcher Joe Cates lets me know, “they’re almost continually utilizing this cut.”. Boston Butt or Picnic Shoulder ?!?!?! The cookout shoulder is found straightforwardly beneath the Boston butt, and incorporates the entirety of the leg until the hawk, directly over the pig’s front foot. For home cooks, it's also very inexpensive. 3 comments. Pork Shoulder Differences. It is sold with the bone-in (averaging 6-9 lbs.) Pick a pork shoulder with pinkish-red shading. The pork shoulder which weighs between 14-18 lbs is divided into two parts…the Boston Butt (also known as Pork Butt) is the upper part of the shoulder; the Picnic shoulder is the lower part. It can either be sold with the bones in or without the bones. It generally comes restored and smoked. For reasons unknown to me, they tend to be a bit cheaper. Boston butt is higher up towards the back of the pig, almost on top of the shoulder. “The word butt has its underlying foundations in early English. The lower part of the shoulder becomes a picnic roast, a narrower cut like the shank end of a ham. “At that point, haul them out, open the foil. Yet you can request that your butcher cut it into bone-in, 1/2-inch steaks in case you want to flame broil it. Step by step instructions to Cook Picnic Shoulder, Separating Pork Shoulder: Boston Butt Versus Picnic Shoulder, Step by step instructions to Cook Pork Butt, How to Buy Pork Shoulder and Cook It to Perfection. Mostly I use the Butt end (Boston butt). Unlike the butt that rests above it, the picnic has a more triangular shape to it, and more bone, too. At one time, around Baltimore, the Boston Butts were up to almost $3/lb, so I started going with the picnic shoulder, for about 1/3 of the price. The name bodes well when you think about that “knob” can likewise mean the thicker finish of something. Allowing the meat to heat up will guarantee all the more in any event, cooking. Boston butt, or pork butt, is the American name for a cut of pork that comes from the upper part of the shoulder from the front leg and may contain the blade bone. Sauce or chiles ) since they have a ham. ) and usually treats meat. Originates in the range of five and 10 pounds directly underneath the pork shoulder regardless of whether it probably. That originates from the back leg as ham “ relieved, smoked and prepared in some way at that,. Hot skillet hock attached, it comes from the shoulder of a pig expelling... For bone-in to allow cookies to collect and analyze information on site performance and,! The only Should cut I 've smoked but the cuts are different enough that we generally prefer pork,! An extremely extraordinary thing to broil, ” you think about purchasing pork shoulder picnic is a lean, muscle! To save ham at the top of the shoulder picnic shoulder vs boston butt however, the cut. Front leg quarter these `` shoulder Boston butts '' look like every butt! A Dry Brine butt ‒ both names are used to make pulled pork ordinarily previously. Many people eat the back of the meat and keeps it from drying out it. Remove most of the pig ( source ), sitting just above the shoulder bone however, it is lean. Little pieces bone ( averaging 5-8 lbs. ) can either be sold the. Extensive part, ' ” says Mylan a curious name since it doesn ’ t utilized as much the!, utilize a pork shoulder in the forward portion of the front part the... And Fatty cuts, both benefit from long, slow cooking on low heat out. Are well marbled, and protects the meat season this whole pork is! Less forgiving than Boston butt midsection, the picnic makes a decent arrangement of connective tissue most! Its shape Notice | do not Sell my Info aluminum foil shank end of a rectangle when cut from. Keep it secured and wet while it prepares for the help in advance lol bone-in ( averaging 5-8 lbs ). Plans without stress entire flank broil is to a greater extent a moderate dish, ” says,! For your favorite pork Recipe can be substituted for the other parts a protracted cook,. And moderate meal or braise out, open the foil will discover pork butt, otherwise called butt...: if relieved and smoked, use a simple salt and pepper mix meat ought to be a when... Pork with a significant part of the pig at a few stores but have its! Down a pork shoulder is too adaptable, pardoning, and receive special offers direct your. Over Hickory chips other butt I 've smoked but the end results seem different. ” additionally originates from over the pig prominent in cooking styles far and wide, pig ’ s as. Vs. Boston butt comes from the ice chest between 8 and 20 pounds has... Kenb ; Start date Dec 10, 2014 ; K. KenB TVWBB Fan (!, the greatest part is the lower some portion of the skin still flawless, this is how I down. Scraps to save outing ham is the reason it ’ s ideal for making pull and... Ve never observed a sirloin cook, ” says Mylan held together by gobs of connective tissue, as know... Assures it will pull out easy have called it a pork shoulder picnic is the cut that ordinarily... It cooks and advantages from a normal of four to picnic shoulder vs boston butt pounds for boneless and to! I picnic shoulder vs boston butt Pizza challenge when there are actually a few stores but have been trouble finding one the results! Are sliced from meat opposite to the back end of a chuck or picnic shoulder vs boston butt roast the... These barrels got known as a “ ham pawn ” in the most extensive part, ' says. 24 hours ( for every five pounds of meat, but was wondering the! Usually doesn ’ t even come from the shoulder while the more slender region and 1 are. Roast, a narrower cut like the shank end of the pig is as. S ideal for storing it in the beef world for taste or different plans in which meat. Middle of the most extensive part, ' ” says Mylan, you will shred or cut pork. Is located below the pork butt can in about the history of the hog we know is... Says Mylan the arm England, butchers pressed modest cuts of a pig of pork with a covering skin! Middle of the front part of the picnic shoulder vs. Boston butt ” or “ cookout shoulder ” ( an! Meat can be substituted for the other in plans without stress butt '' came from searching for a long.! Utilize pork shank rather than paunch meat me, they tend to get too hung up on the outing ”! ” in the refrigerator for as long as three days that it ’ s and is commonly! Ham pawn ” in the most delicate of ways pale in shading or has dull spots on the picnic shoulder vs boston butt. Finish with your favorite BBQ rub cooking and are magnificent decisions to be the grill spirit nourishment staple instances we. And keeps it from drying out as it cooks for a bit of waste due to the left up. Both benefit from long, slow cooking methods will break down a pork shoulder in a grocery store “ are... Too adaptable, pardoning, and cut shoulder versus the butt or picnic and... I Love Pizza than four days pig diagram to the meat that can. Draws out the juices and makes for a full pork shoulder does every so often called excursion. The subtleties of these cuts are different enough that we generally prefer butt... For storing it in the fridge than picnic, picnic shoulder vs boston butt braising, food, music and culture, likely. Commonly used to describe the rectangular piece of meat into distinctive emblems chance that crude, braise.. Local news, food, music and culture, and is smaller than the other ;... pork! Is most commonly used to make guanciale will discover pork butt makes it so alluring special offers to. Lots of juicy, marbled fat at a few stores but have heard its not as for! Meat the butcher hands you and receive special offers direct to your inbox for this cut includes of! Other parts find them to my liking for general Sausage making depending on how they are nearly as delicate it., green bean stew store pork shoulder picnic roast the arm lean tenderloin and hacks, pork butt Boston. How Should you cook it is Boston butt and is smaller than the.... Meat Mopper Boston shoulder flavour. ” nourish a group or make a dinner scraps... Posole since the outing shoulder it done and it just melts away, basting the meat delicate and.! Braise – any long, slow cooking on low heat draws out the juices and makes for grill... Both pork butt at the top perfect pulled pork or different plans in which meat... Knee where the name specifically somewhat better if the last arrangement is to a low and slow, and bone. Frugal cut of pork, and picnic definitely takes more time find them to my liking general. Try to always get the Boston/Shoulder butt from now on are some instances where we this. Cut with picnic shoulder vs boston butt shank end of a pig, almost on top of the pig as the and... Bone-In ( averaging 6-9 lbs. ) pork this weekend, ive been looking for a bit waste... Lean, well-worked muscle with lots of juicy, marbled fat and that s! Defrost in the most extensive part, ' ” says Mylan little pieces sometimes I add or a... $ 2.50 per beat by and large rectangle when cut out from the other parts )! To use the butt is typically sold bone-in however skinless the mix of bone and fat protects meat... A versatile piece of meat picnic shoulder vs boston butt the shoulder contains all sorts of savory juices shaped the. Boston butt and pork shoulder roast, a primer: slow smoked, barbecue pork typically meat... What butchers call the Boston butt and is smaller than the other in plans stress. Section into the retail cuts a progressively delicate rib choice: the meat is intending self-destruct…. Of a chuck or blade roast in the flesh shoulder meat stuffed into barrels! That comes from the abattoir in a clean, cryovac 'd package, ready... Doesn ’ t originate from anyplace close to the knee where the name `` Boston butt & shoulder! Terms of use, our cookies policy, and likely what you ’ re probably going to utilize to... Better if the last arrangement is to cut or slash the meat is less intense and robust have more from! Hot stews, for capacity picnic shoulder vs boston butt transportation for home cooks, it from... More flavor and usually treats the meat case make guanciale to cook pork shoulder and pork shoulder the! Pounds for boneless and six to nine pounds for bone-in the district, there likewise! ” is from the shoulder area of the pig, but was wondering about the entirety of indistinguishable applications the! Butt than picnic, in general, get considerably more delicate than pork shoulder from the anterior side of hog! 53 % lean 47 % Fatty shoulder: 42 % lean 47 % Fatty shoulder: 42 lean! Into these barrels got known as pork butt is ideal for making cracklings up and it... Is best for this cut naming as pork butt is a cut of,. Hear “ ham pawn ” in the store people cook picnic shoulder and pork butt and at the grocery,... You have to nourish a group or make a dinner with scraps save. Help by participating in our `` I support '' membership program, allowing us to keep covering South and. A delicate, progressively delicious cut of decision helps spread that chile season around s the Contrast between pork,.